Think back to someone you fancied years ago. Perhaps it was a film star, someone at work or the person your friends still refuse to let you forget.
Would they have the same effect on you now?
You might still recognise the appeal. Or you might wonder how you overlooked the dreadful conversation because you liked their smile. Meanwhile, someone you once barely noticed—a quieter personality, a different look, someone older than your usual preference—might suddenly seem rather interesting.
It is tempting to put all this down to getting older and wiser. Yet the research offers a less tidy story. Some preferences differ with age. Others seem remarkably persistent. And knowing what you find attractive on paper is only part of understanding who gets under your skin.
Some things change less than you might expect
The familiar story says that youth is about good looks and later life is about personality. It sounds plausible, but it doesn’t stand up particularly well as a universal rule.
In a study published in Human Nature in 2023, Laura Botzet and colleagues examined ideal long-term partner preferences among more than 17,000 single heterosexual women aged 18 to 67, across 147 countries. Differences associated with age were negligible or absent for several qualities, including attractiveness, kindness and supportiveness, financial security, and intelligence and education. Botzet and colleagues, 2023.
Kindness, in other words, wasn’t something women suddenly discovered later in life. Nor did an appreciation of good looks conveniently disappear after a particular birthday.
There were differences elsewhere. Older respondents tended to express a stronger preference for confidence and assertiveness, and accepted a broader partner age range, including relatively younger partners. These were patterns across different women, however—not evidence that every individual’s tastes change in that direction as she ages.
That distinction matters. A survey comparing a 25-year-old with a 55-year-old cannot tell us exactly what the younger person will want thirty years later.
Attraction has more than one ingredient
Research into sexual attraction also suggests that the balance is complicated.
A 2021 study led by Stephen Whyte, published in PLOS ONE, asked 7,325 Australian respondents aged 18 to 65 about nine characteristics, including physical appearance, intelligence, trust, openness and emotional connection. Men and women showed broadly similar patterns in their responses, alongside differences in the importance they assigned to particular qualities. The relative emphasis also varied across age groups. Whyte and colleagues, 2021.
This was research about stated preferences, rather than an observation of who actually sparked desire when people met. Still, its range of questions is a useful reminder of how much the word “attractive” contains.
Someone can be beautiful without making you curious. Someone else can become compelling halfway through a conversation.
Imagine an evening when the person you noticed first barely features in your thoughts afterwards. Instead, you keep remembering the person who made you laugh, understood a reference nobody else caught, or seemed completely comfortable in their own company. It is an ordinary enough possibility, but difficult to capture in a list of preferred features.
What happens when a face becomes a person
A different line of research offers a clue to why our personal favourites don’t always match other people’s judgements.
In a 2015 study of 167 couples, Lucy Hunt, Paul Eastwick and Eli Finkel examined how long partners had known each other before dating. Couples who became involved quickly tended to be more closely matched in physical attractiveness, as rated by independent observers. That matching was weaker among couples who had known each other longer before becoming romantically involved. Hunt, Eastwick and Finkel, 2015.
The finding doesn’t prove that friendship creates desire, and it wasn’t a study of ageing. It does suggest that the circumstances in which people get acquainted deserve a place in the story of attraction.
A photograph gives you appearance. Knowing someone gives you their voice, their timing, their manner and a history of moments together. The researchers proposed that becoming acquainted may allow more individual impressions to matter.
That helps explain why “What do you see in them?” can be such an impossible question to answer. The person asking may never have seen what you have.
Perhaps the surprise is the interesting part
There is another possibility worth considering: sometimes your tastes haven’t changed as much as the experience you are looking for.
Picture someone who once imagined every promising connection leading towards a shared home and family. Years later, they might want affection and excitement while keeping their independence. The qualities that appeal could be familiar, even though the life they hope to build around them is different.
That is a possibility, rather than a rule about age. None of these studies can supply a timetable for an individual’s desires, and preferences for a long-term partner aren’t automatically the same as attraction to a casual lover.
Perhaps that leaves us with a more interesting thought than “your type changes as you get older”. You can have longstanding preferences and still encounter someone who surprises you.
The old favourite might retain every bit of their appeal. But there is something rather enjoyable about discovering that someone you would never have put on your imaginary list has become the person you hope to hear from.
